Palmer Lake Couple Faces Felony Charges in Alleged Water Theft Scheme
A Palmer Lake couple, Terry and Katrina Tolbert, face felony charges for allegedly stealing over 4 million gallons of water during a drought in the Pikes Peak region to fill their pond and replenish greenery. Investigations by town employees and…
Colorado Springs Pueblo, CO, November 9, 2026 — A Palmer Lake couple, identified as Terry and Katrina Tolbert, are now facing felony charges in connection with an alleged water theft scheme that authorities say involved the removal of over 4 million gallons of water. The alleged activity took place during a period of drought affecting the Pikes Peak region.
According to reports, the water was allegedly used by the couple to fill their pond and maintain greenery on their property. The investigation into the matter was reportedly conducted by town employees and the El Paso County Sheriff’s Office. These investigations are said to have uncovered evidence of unauthorized water taps.
Discrepancies were also noted in water audits, contributing to the charges now filed against the Tolberts. The specific details of the audit findings and the exact timeline of the alleged water diversion were not immediately provided.
The couple has been charged with felony offenses related to the alleged theft. The exact nature of the felony charges and further details regarding the legal proceedings are pending. The investigation into the alleged water theft highlights concerns over water resource management, particularly during periods of drought in the region.
The El Paso County Sheriff’s Office was involved in the investigation, alongside town employees. The total volume of water allegedly stolen, over 4 million gallons, represents a significant amount, raising questions about the scale of the alleged operation and its impact on local water resources during a critical time for supply.
Further information regarding the evidence collected, including the unauthorized water taps and audit discrepancies, is expected to be released as the legal process unfolds. The names of the specific town employees involved in the investigation were not disclosed.
Story summarized from the original created by Cleo Westin on gazette.com, see more information here.
Media gallery
